Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021._ FILED. IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF OREGON pop -| AMIO: 0] ANDY NGO, iit JUDICIAL DIST. Plaintiff-Respondent, . V. - ROSE CITY ANTIFA, an unincorporated association; et al, , Defendants and BENJAMIN BOLEN, an individual, Defendant-Appellant. Multnomah County Circuit Court Case No. 20CV19618 A175559 DEFENDANT BENJAMIN BOLEN’S AMENDED NOTICE OF APPEAL 1. Defendant Benjamin Bolen (“Appellant”) hereby gives notice of appeal from the Limited Judgment Denying Special Motion to Strike Pursuant to ORS 31.150, signed by The Honorable Kathleen Dailey on February 17, 2021. The Limited Judgment was entered by the Court on March 17, 2021. Mil Mil Mit Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021._ 2. The parties to this appeal are: Appellant: Benjamin Bolen Respondent: Andy Ngo 3. The names, bar numbers, addresses, and telephone numbers of the lawyers for the parties are: Appellants: Jonathan Henderson, Oregon State Bar No. 063554 Email: jhenderson@davisrothwell.com Hilary A. Boyd, Oregon State Bar No. 163478 Email: hboyd@davisrothwell.com Davis Rothwell Earle & Xdéchihua, P.C. 111 S.W. Fifth Avenue, Suite 2700 Portland, Oregon 97204-3650 Tel: 503-222-4422 Fax: 503-222-4428 Respondent: James L Buchal, Oregon State Bar No. 21618 Email: counsel@buchal.com Murphy & Buchal LLP 3425 S.E. Yamhill, Suite 100 Portland OR 97214 Harmeet K. Dhillon, admitted Pro Hac Vice Email: harmeet@dhillonlaw.com Dhillon Law Group Inc. 177 Post Street, Suite 700 San Francisco, California 94108 4. Appellant designates the record regarding the special motion to strike pursuant to ORS 31.150, including the trial court file, all exhibits, and the record of the oral proceedings regarding that motion. Appellants hereby request copies at Appellants’ Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021._ expense of the audio record designated herein. Copies are to be served on the parties to this appeal listed in paragraph 3 of this Notice of Appeal. 5. Attached to this Amended Notice of Appeal is a copy of the Limited Judgment Denying Special Motion to Strike Pursuant to ORS 31.150, entered by the Court on March 17, 2021. 6. This appeal is timely and otherwise procedurally properly before the Court of Appeals under ORS 19.255 and 19.260 because Appellants have filed the Notice of Appeal within 30 days of the February 17, 2021 signing of the Limited Judgment Denying Special Motion to Strike Pursuant to ORS 31.150, and this Amended Notice of Appeal within 30 days of the entry date for the Limited Judgment of March 17, 2021. The trial court retained jurisdiction to enter the signed judgment, notwithstanding the fact that appellant filed a notice of appeal before the judgment was filed but after it was signed. 7. I certify that I served a copy of this Amended Notice of Appeal on March 23, 2021, by mailing the Notice of Appeal by certified mail, return receipt requested, with the United States Postal Service to: James L Buchal (OSB #921618) Harmeet K. Dhillon, Pro Hac Vice counsel@buchal.com harmeet@dhillonlaw.com Murphy & Buchal LLP Dhillon Law Group Inc. 3425 S.E. Yamhill, Suite 100 177 Post Street, Suite 700 Portland OR 97214 San Francisco, California 94108 Of Attorneys for Plaintiff Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021._ David D. Park, OSB #803358 Elliott & Park, P.C. 324 S Abernethy Street Portland, OR 97239-8529 Tele: 503- 227-1690 Fax: 503- 274-8384 dave@elliott-park.com Of Attorneys for John Hacker David F. Sugerman, OSB #862984 SUGERMAN LAW OFFICE 707 SW Washington St., Ste. 600 Portland, OR 97205 Tel: 503-228-6474 Fax: 503-228-2556 david@sugermanlawoffice.com Of Attorneys for John Hacker Christopher A. Larsen, OSB # 910679 PICKETT DUMMIGAN MCCALL LLP 210 SW Morrison St., 4th FL Portland, Oregon 97204 Tel: 503-223-7770 Fax: 503-227-5350 chris@pdm.legal Of Attorneys for John Hacker Gabriel Chase, OSB # 142948 CHASE LAW, PC 621 S.W. Alder St., Ste. 600 Portland, OR 97205 Tel: 503-294-1414 Fax: 503-294-1455 gabriel@chaselawc.net Of Attorneys for John Hacker Michelle R Burrows, OSB # 861606 MICHELLE R. BURROWS P.C. 1333 Orenco Station Parkway# 525 Hillsboro, OR 97124 Tel: 503-241-1955 michelle.r.burrows@gmail.com Of Attorneys for John Hacker Jane L. Moisan, OSB # 181864 PEOPLE'S LAW PROJECT 818 S.W. 4th Ave. #221-3789 Portland, OR 97204 Tel: 971-258-1292 peopleslawproject@gmail.com Of Attorneys for John Hacker Joe Piucci, OSB # 135325 Stephen Piucci, OSB #821056 PIUCCI LAW LLC 900 SW 13th Ave., Ste. 200 Portland, OR 97205 Tel: 503-228-7385 Fax: 503-228-2571 joe@piucci.com steve@piucci.com Of Attorneys for John Hacker Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021._ I further certify that I filed the original of this Amended Notice of Appeal on March 22, 2021, via certified mail, return receipt requested with the Appellate Court Administrator, Appellate Court Records Section, 1163 State Street, Salem, Oregon. DATED this 23nd day of March, 2021. DAVIS ROTHWELL EARLE & XOCHIHUA, P.C. /s/Jonathan Henderson Jonathan Henderson, OSB #063554 jhenderson@davisrothwell.com Hilary A. Boyd, OSB No. 152095 hboyd@davisrothwell.com Of Attorneys for Defendant Bolen Page 2. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE DAVIS ROTHWELL EARLE & XOCHIHUA, P.C. 200 SW MARKET ST, SuITE 1800 PORTLAND, OREGON 97201 T (503) 222-4422 F (503) 222-4428 Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021._ 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Page 1 20CV19618 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE STATE OF OREGON FOR THE COUNTY OF MULTNOMAH ANDY NGO, Plaintiff, v. ROSE CITY ANTIFA, an unincorporated association; BENJAMIN BOLEN, an individual; JOHN HACKER, an individual; CORBYN (KATHERINE) BELYEA, an individual; JOSEPH CHRISTIAN EVANS, an individual; MADISON LEE ALLEN, an individual; DOES 1-50, Defendants. Nw Nee Nee Nee ee ee” ee ee” ee” ee” ee” ee” ee” ee” Se” ee” Case No. 20CV19618 LIMITED JUDGMENT DENYING SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE PURSUANT TO ORS 31.150 Defendant Benjamin Bolen moved to strike Plaintiff's claims against him pursuant to ORS 31.150. The Court entered an order denying defendant Benjamin Bolen’s Special Motion to Strike on December 21, 2020. ORS 31.150(1) instructs that if the Court denies such a motion, the Court shall enter a limited judgment denying the motion. Mil Mil Mil Hil Mit LIMITED JUDGMENT DENYING SPECIAL MOTION TO DAVIS ROTHWELL STRIKE PURSUANT TO ORS 31.150 EARLE & XOCHIAUA, P.C. 200 SW MARKET ST, SUITE 1800 PORTLAND, OREGON 97201 T (S03) 222-4422 F (503) 222-4428 Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021._ 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 As such, and consistent with this Court’s December 21, 2020 Order and Opinion denying the motion, this Court orders that this judgment denying defendant Benjamin Bolen’ Special Motion to Strike be entered forthwith. Signed: 2/17/2021 11:22 AM Koei) Dre, Gireutt Court Ju SUBMITTED BY: Hilary A. Boyd, OSB No. 152095 hboyd@davisrothwell.com Jonathan Henderson, OSB No. 063554 jhenderson@davisrothwell.com Of Attorneys for Defendant Bolen Page 2 LIMITED JUDGMENT DENYING SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE PURSUANT TO ORS 31.150 nM. rt Judag Kathto6n M. Dalley DAVIS ROTHWELL EARLE & XOCHIHUA, P.C. 200 SW MARKET ST, SUITE 1800 PORTLAND, OREGON 97201 T (503) 222-4422 F (503) 222-4428 Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021._ 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Page 1 UTCR 5.100 CERTIFICAT I certify this proposed judgment/order is ready for judicial signature because (check all that apply): Oo Service is not required under UTCR 5.100 (1)(c) because the other party has been found in default or an order of default is being requested with this proposed judgment/order; because this judgment/order is submitted ex parte as allowed by statute or rule; or this judgment/order is being submitted in open court with all parties present. o Each party affected by this judgment/order has stipulated to or approved the judgment/order, as shown by the signatures on the judgment/order, or by written confirmation sent to me. : I have served a copy of this judgment/order and the Notice of Proposed Judgment/order to all parties entitled to service on January 21, 2021 and: 7 No objection has been served on me. o I received objections that I could not resolve with the other party despite reasonable efforts to do so. I have filed with the court a copy of the objections I received and indicated which objections remain unresolved. a After conferring about objections, the other party agreed to file any remaining objection with the court. DATED this 27" day of January, 2021. DAVIS ROTHWELL EARLE & XOCHIHUA, P.C. /s/ Jonathan Henderson Hilary A. Boyd, OSB No. 152095 hboyd@davisrothwell.com Jonathan Henderson, OSB No. 063554 jhenderson@davisrothwell.com Of Attorneys for Defendant Bolen CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE DAVIS ROTHWELL EARLE & XOCHIHUA, P.C. 200 SW MARKET ST, SUITE 1800 PORTLAND, OREGON 97201 T (503) 222-4422 F (503) 222-4428 Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021._ I CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 2 I hereby certify that I served the foregoing LIMITED JUDGMENT DENYING 3. SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE PURSUANT TO ORS 31.150 on the following attorney(s) 4 _ of record: 5 James L Buchal (OSB #921618) counsel@buchal.com 6 Murphy & Buchal LLP 3425 S.E. Yamhill, Suite 100 7 Portland OR 97214 8 Harmeet K. Dhillon, Pro Hac Vice harmeet@dhillonlaw.com 9 Dhillon Law Group Inc. 177 Post Street, Suite 700 10 San Francisco, California 94108 Of Attorneys for Plaintiff 1] 12. David D. Park, OSB #803358 Elliott & Park, P.C. 13. 3248S Abernethy Street Portland, OR 97239-8529 14 Tele: 503- 227-1690 Fax: 503- 274-8384 15 dave@elliott-park.com Of Attorneys for John Hacker 16 Michelle R Burrows, OSB # 861606 17. MICHELLE R. BURROWS P.C. 1333 Orenco Station Parkway# 525 18 Hillsboro, OR 97124 Tel: 503-241-1955 19 michelle.r.burrows@gmail.com Of Attorneys for John Hacker 20 David F. Sugerman, OSB #862984 21 SUGERMAN LAW OFFICE 707 SW Washington St., Ste. 600 22 ~~‘ Portland, OR 97205 Tel: 503-228-6474 23. Fax: 503-228-2556 david@sugermanlawoffice.com 24 Of Attorneys for John Hacker 250 Hil Page 2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Christopher A. Larsen, OSB # 910679 PICKETT DUMMIGAN MCCALL LLP 210 SW Morrison St., 4th FL Portland, Oregon 97204 Tel: 503-223-7770 Fax: 503-227-5350 chris@pdm.legal Of Attorneys for John Hacker Gabriel Chase, OSB # 142948 CHASE LAW, PC 621 S.W. Alder St., Ste. 600 Portland, OR 97205 Tel: 503-294-1414 Fax: 503-294-1455 abriel(@chaselawc.net Of Attorneys for John Hacker Jane L. Moisan, OSB # 181864 PEOPLE'S LAW PROJECT 818 S.W. 4th Ave. #221-3789 Portland, OR 97204 Tel: 971-258-1292 peopleslawproject@gmail.com Of Attorneys for John Hacker Joe Piucci, OSB # 135325 Stephen Piucci, OSB #821056 PIUCCI LAW LLC 900 SW 13th Ave., Ste. 200 Portland, OR 97205 Tel: 503-228-7385 Fax: 503-228-2571 joe@piucci.com Of Attorneys for John Hacker DAVIS ROTHWELL EARLE & XOCHIHUA, P.C. 200 SW MARKET ST, SUITE 1800 PORTLAND, OREGON 97201 T (503) 222-4422 F (503) 222-4428 1 by mailing to the foregoing a true copy thereof, placed in a sealed envelope, with postage 3 __ post office at Portland, Oregon, on this day. 4 DATED this 27" day of January, 2021. Verified Correct Copy of Original 4/1/2021. 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Page2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 2 prepaid, addressed as listed above, and depositing the same in the United States mail through a DAVIS ROTHWELL EARLE & XOCHIHUA, P.C. /s/ Jonathan Henderson Hilary A. Boyd, OSB No. 152095 hboyd@davisrothwell.com Jonathan Henderson, OSB No. 063554 jhenderson@davisrothwell.com Of Attorneys for Defendant Bolen DAVIS ROTHWELL EARLE & XOCHIAUA, P.C. 200 SW MARKET ST, SUITE 1800 PORTLAND, OREGON 97201 T (503) 222-4422 F (503) 222-4428